Resembling an iconic Chicago dessert, buckeye coffee cake is a chocolate cake with cinnamon-peanut filling and a peanut butter custard baked on top.

While searching for a recipe to Buck-ify for the game against Northwestern today I stumbled upon something called the “New Look” cake created by the Bakers Dozen in the 1950s – because of course Chicago has a secret society of bakers.
At first I thought I was out of luck because not only is the New Look cake recipe a closely guarded secret, Jarosch Bakery being the only bakery that sells it, the Bakers Dozen ordered custom pans for them! Evidently they are square with a round hole in the middle, like a square bundt cake. Have you ever had the secret New Look cake? I feel like I need to plan a trip to Chicago just to try it.

I was prepared to power through with a standard round bundt pan or a 9×9 square baking pan to make a buckeye New Look coffee cake but then I remembered inheriting a weird pan that was stashed somewhere in my kitchen. I originally thought it might be for angel food cake but after seeing the New Look cake I started to think my grandmother might have had ties to this secret baking society.
Maybe secret pan in hand, I set out to make a buckeye New Look cake, except I named it a buckeye coffee cake just in case the name is trademarked. I don’t need the Chicago bakers-mob to come after me. But mostly because it turns out my initial assumption was correct. I spotted a “Wear-Ever 2740” stamped on the bottom while cleaning the pan after baking and a quick Google search revealed that it is a vintage angel food cake tube pan. Regardless, I am convinced the New Look cake pan can’t look that much differently so I’m sticking to it.

The original cake is a butter pecan coffee cake with custard filling around the hole in the middle but of course I didn’t have their recipe to work from so I adapted my Chocolate Peanut Butter Coffee Cake. As the name would imply, this buckeye coffee cake has a chocolate base, peanuts instead of pecans, and a ring of peanut butter custard. The end result kind of looks like a very rough Block O which is even more perfect.
Want more recipes like this? You would also enjoy my Buckeye Bundt Cake, Buckeye Banana Bread, Buckeye Muffins, or Buckeye Scones.

- Four years ago: White Chocolate Glazed Cranberry Orange Scones
- Seven years ago: Eggs Benedict Quiche
- Eight years ago: Lentil Taco Skillet
- Ten years ago: Coconut-Pumpkin Pie
- Eleven years ago: Peanut Butter & Chocolate Kitchen Sink Cookie Bars
- Twelve years ago: Spatchcocked Turkey with Champagne-Thyme Gravy
- Thirteen years ago: Overnight, Slow Cooker Ice Cream Oatmeal
- Fourteen years ago: Cashew Chicken Lettuce Wraps
- Fifteen years ago: Chicken Alfredo Biscuit Casserole
Source: Adapted from my Chocolate Peanut Butter Coffee Cake and Amy Kay’s Kitchen.
