Big, chewy peanut butter cookies just like you remember from school lunches! These come with the added bonus of Reese’s pieces mixed in.
Before I baked these, Brent saw the bag of Reeses Pieces and said, “what is this?” in an accusatory tone. He is on a diet right now, preparing for Medical Officer basic training in July and keeping unhealthy things away has been key.
Actually, the key has been to hide the goodies so that I don’t have to be completely on his diet as well. I need fat and sugar!!
That’s where these cookies come in to play. They are sooo soft. They may be undercooked but I wouldn’t have them any other way. That peanut butter-honey mixture is essential and then the Reeses Pieces seal the deal.
Elle’s New England Kitchen made a huge batch (75!) of medium sized (3 inch) cookies from the original recipe. But I can only hide so many cookies around here, so I took a chance and halved the recipe (with a little extra flour). Making large cookies this version came out to 2 dozen ridiculously good cookies.
BTW, I think I have a serious addiction to baked goods – I continue to turn on my oven despite the ongoing heat vs A/C battle. (Totally worth it.)
Post updated 5/28/20, photo above is the original.
PEANUT BUTTER MIXTURE
- 1 cup creamy peanut butter
- 4 Tbsp (1/2 stick) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 1/4 cup honey
- 3 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 tsp baking powder
- 1/2 tsp baking soda
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 3/4 cup (1-1/2 stick) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 1/4 cup shortening, room temperature
- 1 cup sugar
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 2 eggs, room temperature
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- 2 cups Reeses Pieces
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Line your baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats, set aside.
- In a medium bowl, blend together all of the peanut butter mixture ingredients until smooth. Set aside.
- In another medium bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Set aside.
- In a large bowl, cream the butter, shortening, and both sugars until light and fluffy. Add the eggs, beating well after each one, then add vanilla and peanut butter mixture. Add the flour mixture by the cupful and beat at low speed until fully mixed. Stir in the candy by hand.
- Using a 1/4 cup scoop, place balls of dough about 2 inches apart on your baking sheet.
- Bake for 11-13 minutes (they will still be pale, with a touch of golden brown on the bottom edges). Allow to cool for 10 minutes, then move to a cooling rack using a spatula. Let cool completely and then store in an airtight container.
Source: Adapted from Elle’s New England Kitchen.
Did you make this recipe? I want to see!
Tag @THESPIFFYCOOKIE on Instagram and hashtag it #THESPIFFYCOOKIE
[…] all the peanut butter cups for Valentine’s Day you should also consider making my Lunch Lady reese’s pieces peanut butter cookies, chocolate reese’s pieces cookies if you prefer more chocolate, or even a reese’s […]
I’m confused on the amount of butter 4 tbsp is not 1/2 a stick and 3/4 cup is not 1.5 sticks.
The sticks of butter I use are 1/2 cup (8 Tbsp), so that’s how it works out for me!
I bake all summer. I can’t help myself. And anything with Reese’s Pieces sounds amazing.
Better than my moms!
I’d have to agree. One of my favorites!
Hey, Erin! I stumbled upon this post! :) Gave you a big thumb up! :)
Thank you so much! I love these cookies.
Peanutbutter cookies are quite wonderful!
I can’t wait to try these!
Oh my goodness you’ll love them!
Ohhh, my heavens. Now, I loved your skillet chicken recipe. Parmesan-roasted broccoli? Fabulous. But you know what? I love me some baked goods. I need my fat and sugar too.
They were very very amazingly good!
I try to rationalize my summer baking by doing it first thing in the morning before the temperature soars. ;)
Such yummy looking cookies. Peanut butter heaven.
Definitely peanut butter heaven.
Oh my gosh, they look fantastic! Just like mine did, which has now given me a huge craving to make them again. They really are my favorite cookie, even topping the ever loved chocolate chip. Halving the batch was a good idea, since the regular size makes so many!
Thanks for the shout out! :)
No problem, thanks for the recipe!
Is there anything better than a peanut butter cookie? I think NOT!