Buckeye Tin Roof Sundae

by Erin

As a peanut butter version of a classic ice cream treat, Buckeye tin roof sundae is a winner in my book.

Buckeye Tin Roof Sundae.

November may not be the best time to unveil a ice cream sundae recipe but today my Ohio State Buckeyes are on the road to play the Nebraska Cornhuskers and we can thank the tiny town of Potter, Nebraska for inventing the tin roof ice cream sundae around 1916 at The Potter Sundry. Harold Dean “Pinky” Thayer came up with the combination of chocolate ice cream topped with chocolate sauce followed by vanilla ice cream topped with marshmallow cream and a sprinkle of Spanish peanuts.

But why is it called a “tin roof” sundae? Allegedly it come from hearing the peanuts dropping onto a metal plate/counter, which sounded like raindrops on a tin roof. Others say it’s because the shop had tin ceiling tiles. Either way you know I had to make a Buckeye tin roof sundae using peanut butter ice cream instead.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Tin Roof Sundae.

So how do you make a Buckeye tin roof sundae? Start with a large scoop of chocolate ice cream (I used Graeter’s Buckeye Blitz) topped with chocolate hot fudge followed by another large scoop of peanut butter ice cream (I used Velvet’s Buckeye Classic) topped with marshmallow cream, a sprinkle of peanuts, actual sprinkles, and a homemade buckeye for good measure.

Don’t want ice cream this time of year? Nebraska is also take their cinnamon rolls seriously, making them a cornerstone of local culture. To prove it, since the mid 20th century, school cafeterias in Nebraska have been serving a cinnamon roll as a side to a bowl of chili. I love a sweet and savory combo and while this one gives me pause I would still give it a chance. Maybe with a classic cinnamon roll first rather than my peanut butter cinnamon rolls with chocolate glaze or easy chocolate peanut butter cinnamon rolls.

Buckeye Tin Roof Sundae with chocolate and peanut butter ice cream.

Buckeye Tin Roof Sundae.

BUCKEYE TIN ROOF SUNDAE

Print
Yield: 1 Serving Prep Time:
Nutrition facts: 200 calories 20 grams fat

Ingredients

  • 1 large scoop chocolate ice cream
  • 1 Tbsp chocolate hot fudge topping, warmed
  • 1 large scoop peanut butter ice cream
  • 1 Tbsp marshmallow topping, warmed
  • 1 Tbsp peanuts
  • Scarlet and gray sprinkles
  • Homemade buckeye candy

Directions

  1. In a bowl or tumbler, add the scoop of chocolate ice cream and spoon warm hot fudge over the top.
  2. Add peanut butter ice cream and spoon warm marshmallow over the top. 
  3. Sprinkle with peanuts and sprinkles, garnishing with a buckeye.
Did You Make This Recipe?
I want to see! Tag me on Instagram at @TheSpiffyCookie and hashtag it #TheSpiffyCookie.

Source: The Spiffy Cookie original.

You may also like

1 comment

Jim D November 21, 2026 - 1:11 pm

I like how you post some of your chronological recipes. They go way back. Your butter pecan and brandy ice cream. I just make a small
change: one cup of brandy. Improves the football regardless of your favorite.

Reply

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you consent to the storing of your message attached to the e-mail address you've used. (Data will not be shared with any 3rd-parties)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Accept Read More